Common Problems Running Recyclable Mono-Material Films on VFFS Machines

Swap a PET/PE laminate for a recyclable mono-PE film, run it at the same settings, and the first pillow pouches often come off with holes in the seal. A controlled VFFS trial by ExxonMobil and Siegwerk recorded exactly this: bare MDO-PE at 200 °C and a 500 ms dwell gave “bag leaks and hole in the seal.”

The reason is structural, not a settings oversight. In a mono-material film the sealant layer and the load-bearing layer are the same polymer family, so the temperature that seals also softens the web.

A laminate carried a high-melt substrate that held its shape while a low-melt PE skin sealed underneath. That margin is gone, and every problem below cascades from its loss.

Why the Sealing Window Collapses When the Sealant and the Structure Are the Same Polymer

The sealing window — the band between the lowest jaw temperature that bonds and the highest the package survives — narrows because both limits move toward each other. PE skins melt below PP, PET, or nylon, so the moment the jaw fuses the sealant, the structural PE around it is already near its softening point.

Collapsed sealing window of recyclable mono-material films on VFFS machines versus a wide laminate window

The ExxonMobil/Siegwerk trial puts numbers on it. At 200 °C and a fixed 500 ms dwell, the uncoated MDO-PE reference leaked and holed at the seal. The resin maker named the mechanism: “stickiness to the sealing bars and heat-related distortion of the film.” A heat-resistant over-print varnish delivered a sealing-window improvement of greater than 50 percent.

A 2022 NCSU BioResources study found the same squeeze from the other side. A single-web thermoplastic film shrank at 140 °C — barely above the temperature it needed to seal — while the paper reference stayed stable to 220 °C.

Two levers rebuild the window. On the material side, specify an oriented or heat-resistant grade — MDO-PE, BOPE, or heat-resistant-coated PE — or a low-seal-initiation-temperature sealant that drops the bond limit by up to roughly 22 °C.

On the machine side, this is where temperature-controlled sealing jaws earn their cost. Tight closed-loop control holds you inside a window an open-loop band heater would overshoot.

The critical specification to verify is the actual window span on your film at your dwell, not the brochure seal temperature.

How Recyclable Mono-Material Film Mis-Tracks Through the Forming Set

A mono-PE web is more flexible and lower in stiffness than the laminate it replaces, so it transmits tension less rigidly through the forming collar and pull-belts. Sandwiched between the pull belts and the forming tube, a limper web folds and creases under the same pressure that fed the laminate cleanly.

Recyclable mono-material film mis-tracking and wrinkling over a VFFS forming collar

The NCSU study logged exactly these failures: wrinkling, web buckling, and friction in the forming tubes. The break over the forming collar is the hardest moment — Rovema notes many flow-wrapper films cannot run on a VFFS at all because of the sharp change in direction there.

Three adjustments recover tracking:

  • Balance the web tension. Under-tension lets the limp film wander; over-tension necks it down and shifts the print mark past the eye-mark sensor.
  • Match the collar and tube finish. A polished, low-friction collar lets a soft web break over the shoulder without grabbing.
  • Use servo-controlled tension on mixed lines. Holding a setpoint regardless of roll diameter keeps the web path clean instead of chasing registration all shift.

Specify an oriented grade here too. MDO-HDPE and oriented PE replace BOPP and BOPET precisely because they restore stiffness — the grade that widens the seal window also stiffens the web.

How Much VFFS Line Speed Recyclable Mono-Material Film Costs

Plants commonly report single-digit-percentage line-speed reductions on recyclable mono-material when the seal window and tension are set correctly. That is far less than compostable films, which often run at 25 to 60 bags per minute. The derate is a function of dwell and grade, not an inherent penalty of going recyclable.

The cause traces back to the collapsed window. The jaw cannot run as hot without distorting the structural layer, so the seal must be held longer to build strength at a lower temperature. A longer dwell means a longer cycle, which means fewer bags per minute.

A low-SIT sealant buys this back — shorter dwell, faster speeds, fewer channel leakers. It is the same mechanism that sets the speed ceiling on any VFFS film.

Treat the brochure bag-rate as a starting point, not a spec. The two numbers worth trending on a trial are achieved line speed and seal-related scrap rate. If scrap climbs as you push speed, the window is too narrow for that grade — the fix is a wider-window film, not a hotter jaw.

Why Mono-Material Film Feeding and Bag-Opening Problems Trace Back to COF

The film’s coefficient of friction (COF) controls whether the web draws smoothly through the forming set and whether the formed bag opens cleanly. Processing through a packaging machine typically needs a sealing-layer COF against steel of 0.15 to 0.30, and against itself of 0.2 to 0.4.

Too high, and the film drags against the forming tube — feeding stalls, tension spikes, registration drifts. Too low, or with static build-up, and the web layers cling so the bag will not open to fill.

COF is dialed in with additives, and the levers are the film spec you ask for. Slip agents such as erucamide or oleamide run roughly 200 to 2000 ppm; anti-block fillers like silica, talc, or diatomaceous earth run roughly 1000 to 8000 ppm.

Additive migration shifts surface COF over the first days after extrusion, so qualify COF on aged samples, not fresh. State the COF window you need on the purchase order — a grade optimized for recyclability will not arrive machine-ready by default.

How Mono-Material Film Hot Tack and Trapped Product Break the Seal

Mono-PE seals fail two ways the laminate rarely did: poor hot tack and contamination in the seal area. The structural layer is near its softening point at seal temperature, so the fresh hot seal has little green strength to hold product weight before it cools.

Heavier fills pull the seal open, and any dust, powder, or fat in the seal zone keeps it from closing.

Ultrasonic sealing sidesteps both because it does not rely on the heat that distorts the web. The tools stay cool, so there is no hot-tack lag — the seals reach full strength almost immediately. The system also seals through contamination, forming leak-tight seals through slurries of water and vegetable matter.

Ultrasonic versus heat-jaw seal on recyclable mono-material films on VFFS machines

The geometry helps too. Seal thickness drops to 2 mm or less — one case reported 11 percent film savings — and the first bag is good, with none of the warm-up a heat jaw needs.

A VFFS machine built with an ultrasonic sealing system addresses the case where a mono-PE web will not give a reliable heat seal at any safe temperature. Reserve it for the hard cases — heavy fills, fatty or dusty products, or a grade with no heat-resistant option.

For everything else, the heat-resistant grade plus controlled jaws costs less than an ultrasonic retrofit.

How Mono-Material Recyclability Limits Widening the Sealing Window

The recyclability that motivated the switch sets a hard limit on the barrier you can add to widen the seal window. CEFLEX design principles favor mono-PE or mono-PP structures because they sort and recycle cleanly in the existing PE and PP streams — the whole point of running the harder film.

The number to hold is the EVOH ceiling. Current CEFLEX guidance puts the limit around 5 percent by total structure weight to stay PE- or PP-compatible. APR and RecyClass align on roughly the same boundary — up to about 6 percent under a defined EVOH-to-tie-layer ratio.

For the line, this bounds the window-widening levers from the earlier sections. A thin over-print varnish or functional coating is usually compatible. A thick barrier stack pushed in to chase a wider window can tip the structure out of the recyclable category — undoing the reason you took on the runnability problems at all.

Where Most Mono-Material Conversions Go Wrong

The conversions that stall treat mono-material as a drop-in swap and chase the leaking seal with a hotter jaw, which only drives the structural layer further into distortion. Every symptom — leaking seal, wandering web, single-digit speed loss — traces to the same collapsed margin: sealant and structure are now one polymer, so heat that seals also softens.

Diagnose from that root and the fix is the same pair. Specify the right grade — an oriented or heat-resistant PE, a low-SIT sealant, the COF window on the purchase order. Then give the machine the control to live inside the narrow window: temperature-regulated jaws, servo tension for the limp web, ultrasonic sealing where heat alone will not do it.

Keep any barrier under the roughly 5 percent EVOH line, and the runnability you rebuild does not cost you the recyclability you bought it for.

    Comments are closed

    Soontact provides complete packaging solutions for manufacturers worldwide. Contact our packaging engineers to discuss your specific products, production volumes, and packaging material requirements.

    We offer machine demonstrations, application testing, and detailed proposals that address your particular operational needs.

    Get Your Custom Packaging Solution

    Tell us about your product and production needs. Our engineers will recommend the right machine configuration for your application.

    We only use your details to reply to this request.